5 Tactics to Increase Conversions on Your Nonprofit Website

03 Jan 2022 . minute read

Do you want to receive more donations? Be mindful about your Nonprofit’s website and improve your conversion rate. Check out these 5 tips.

Your nonprofit website may be designed to serve multiple purposes, but undeniably, one of the primary purposes is to convert visitors into donors.

Look at your website from a donor’s perspective — does it persuade you to give? Are you able to find all the information you need to be convinced?

To improve your site’s conversions, you must design it in a donor-centric way. Here are five tactics to do just that.

1. Create Short and Impactful Forms

Let’s begin with the end in mind — the ultimate conversion for your nonprofit is a successful donation. A donation form is how you accept donations, which means you must put special care into making it as streamline and impactful as possible.

So, with the help of a professional and easy-to-use online form builder, prioritize building high-converting forms. And to increase form conversions, follow these best practices:

  • Ask only for necessary information such as name, email address, and payment details. The fewer clicks and fields your form has, the higher the conversion rate.
  • Consider breaking it down into a multistep form, with slides for donation amount, contact information, payment, review. This lets donors focus on one step at a time and simplifies the form visually to avoid overwhelm.
  • Provide multiple payment options such as PayPal, credit cards, etc.
  • Offer suggested donation options (one-time or monthly) and amounts that are slightly lower, on par with, and above the average donation to your nonprofit.
  • Showcase security measures (SSL certificate, trust badges, etc.) as donors’ are parting with sensitive personal information. Embed the form directly on your website instead of sending donors to a third-party site.
  • Don’t enforce account creation and login, unless donors wish to save their info for future donations.
  • Reaffirm the purpose and impact of their donation with a crisp copy and photos.
  • Ensure the form is mobile-optimized and loads fast.

2. Showcase Up-to-Date, Accurate Information

Logic dictates that the more trustworthy your website is, the more donations it will garner. So, building your nonprofit’s credibility is one of the first and most important steps in landing more conversions.

Visitors would only consider making a donation if they’re able to learn everything they want to about your nonprofit. This means you must provide information that’s relevant, accurate, up-to-date, to the point, and answers most (if not all) of a potential donor’s questions.

So, make sure to have the following information easily available:

  • Value proposition: A statement that tells your prospects why they should donate to your cause, highlighting what impact their donation will have.
  • Mission and vision: What your organization hopes to achieve in the short and long run.
  • Backstory: Why your nonprofit came into existence.
  • Your leadership structure: Your nonprofit’s executive leadership and board members must be listed with their credentials, affiliations, and headshots.
  • Contact information: Updated contact information of your main office, subsidiary locations if any, and specific staff members.
  • Ongoing programs and fundraisers: Latest updates on any ongoing campaigns and new initiatives.
  • FAQs: A page or section of the website dedicated to answering all potential questions a visitor may have.

All this information helps to build transparency and trustworthiness, which translates to more conversions.

3. A/B Test the Various Elements on Your Site

Split testing, aka A/B testing, is a conversion rate optimization (CRO) technique that involves splitting the various elements (images, copy, buttons, etc.) on your website into two variants and determining which variant drives more conversions.

So A refers to “control” or the original testing variable, and B refers to “variation” or a new version of the element you’re trying to optimize for more conversions.

The version that results in more conversions is called the “winner”. Implementing the changes of this winning variation on your tested pages optimizes your nonprofit website for more donations.

You start with a hypothesis and focus on one change at a time, like the color of a donation button, or the size of the form. Then, using an A/B testing software like Google Optimize, you display the variation to half of your traffic, while the other half sees the original version.

Optimizing your donation form in these ways makes donating an easier and more streamlined experience for prospective donors.

4. Use Storytelling on Your Blog

Storytelling is powerful.

Sharing real stories from real people — past donors, victims, your leadership team, etc. — on your nonprofit website’s blog is a great way to evoke the emotions in prospective donors.

Share an insider perspective of someone who’s positively influenced by your nonprofit’s work. Supplement the story with powerful images and videos. For example, Charity: water shares inspiring stories on their website.

5. Optimize the Post-Donation Experience

As mentioned in the beginning, increasing conversions on your nonprofit website is all about optimizing the on-site experience for your visitors. This includes visitors who have converted into donors.

After all, it’s easier to retain donors than it is to acquire and convert new ones. What’s more, recurring donors’ support and trust in your nonprofit can snowball over time, so you may receive larger donations and word-of-mouth referrals if you make efforts to retain them.

Right after someone completes a donation, the usual process you have in place is to reroute them to a basic confirmation page along with a “thank you” note sent on email. But you can take this a step further by having:

  • Prominent social sharing buttons on the confirmation/thank you page, enabling them to easily share their good deed and encourage others to do the same
  • A quick survey to learn what your donors care about, so as to tailor your future donation appeals
  • An option to sign-up for your newsletter, so as to deliver relevant content and keep them in the loop

Consider a successful donation as the first step in building a long-term relationship with the donor. Based on the campaign(s) they donated for, the amount, and mode of payment, you can personalize your future efforts by:

  • Knowing when to make a donation appeal based on their donation timeline
  • Requesting a generous but realistic gift based on their usual donation amount
  • Emphasizing their preferred mode of payment when requesting a new donation

Long story short, a basic automated “thank you” note suffices, but isn’t ideal for retaining donors and boosting future conversions. So take the time to optimize the post-donation experience, and set yourself up for more and bigger conversions in the future.

Wrapping Up

Increasing your conversions isn’t a one-time effort. It requires continuous testing and optimization, and updating of information and content to create a website that’s compelling and helpful enough to drive more donations.


Interested in working with Diginow? Drop us a line at hello@diginow.co.uk.

We are a Creative Web Design Agency based in London & Leicester, specialising in Bespoke Website Design, Web Development, Branding and Digital Marketing.

Let's make something great together.

Whether it’s a new venture or existing brand. Let us know your ideas below using our project planner and we’ll see how we can help.